I owe thanks to my darling friend Katharine for this dairy free Homemade Bailey’s Pumpkin Spice liqueur. It was after she Whatsapped me a photo of her original version and (after I rolled my tongue back in and closed my mouth) I decided that I too must have access to this delicious sounding tipple. I’ve since realised that we can actually get it here in the UK for a limited time only but that still doesn’t solve the dairy issue.

I’ve made dairy free Homemade Bailey’s original before with much success and it’s proven to be a rather popular post. In fact the post went live at the beginning of December last year. Quite simply, I couldn’t go another Christmas without my favourite cream liqueur and once I’d tried the Bailey’s Almande™ new drink (adding to my disappointment) I knew I had to make my own version and stop relying on someone else to do it for me.

Please note that I really like the Almande™ drink, it’s a lovely light cream liqueur but for me it’s more on par with a Pina colada, not a thick luxurious creamy liqueur like Bailey’s original. The taste isn’t the same either, it’s really a different drink altogether but made by the trademark Bailey’s.

Anyhoo, now that I’ve made this I’ve got plans for more flavours and (hic) really don’t mind doing all the recipe development necessary (hic) until I get it absolutely perfect (hic).

In fact, once you’ve made your own Bailey’s the choices are endless, pour over dairy free ice cream as a treat or use to make my Gluten Free Bailey’s Baked Cheesecake, simply swap the ricotta cheese for a dairy free cream cheese.

5 from 1 vote
Dairy Free Homemade Bailey’s Pumpkin Spice
Not only have I now cracked a recipe for the best tasting dairy free Bailey’s but I’ve also developed a pumpkin spice version to coincide with the current limited edition in the supermarkets. This is a luxurious creamy drink with a warm spicy undertone and yes, it tastes like pumpkin pie!
Author: Glutarama
  • 400 ml tin Coconut Milk needs to be 70% or over in coconut extract
  • 200 Caster Sugar
  • 250 ml  Whisky
  • 250 ml  Soya Milk
  • 250 ml  Soya Cream
  • 2 tbsp  Choc Shot
  • ¼ tsp ground nutmeg
  • ¼ tsp cinnamon
  • ¼ tsp ground cloves
  • ¼ tsp ginger
To make the condensed 'milk'
  1. Tip the contents of the tinned coconut milk into a large saucepan.
  2. Add the 200g caster sugar and stir to combine, the liquid may appear lumpy unless you buy the creamed milk version, don't worry if it is lumpy.
  3. Turn the hob onto full heat and stir until all the coconut lumps have melted, then leave to boil for 20 minutes.
  4. Stir occasionally as the liquid reduces. You want to keep the liquid at a rapid/rolling boil stage (bubbles rolling into the centre of the pan from the edges)
  5. Remove the pan from the heat after 20 minutes, pour into a jug and set on a window sill to cool.
  6. This makes roughly 250ml of condensed ‘milk’ once it’s reduced.
To make the Pumpkin Spice Cream
  1. Simply add all other ingredients to a blender.
  2. Add the cooled condensed 'milk' and blend.
  3. Pour into a 1ltr container, it should just fit perfectly to the top of the bottle, if not I top it up with soya milk or whisky (it depends on how naughty I’m feeling) Pop in the fridge and serve over ice when cooled.
Recipe Notes

This will keep in the fridge for well over a week...Hahaha, as if it will last that long!


Don’t forget it, pin it!

Click to save my Dairy Free Homemade Bailey’s Pumpkin Spice

Homemade Bailey's Pumpkin Spice; gluten free and dairy free. Delicious cream liqueur made with warm winter spices perfect over ice

And one last thing! I’ve linked my Dairy Free Homemade Bailey’s Pumpkin Spice with these other awesome bloggers pages, go check them out

Cook Blog Share | Free From Fridays | Brilliant Blog Posts | Recipe of the Week | Got 2 be Gluten FreeThat Friday Linky | Blog Crush | Cook Once Eat Twice


Bailey's Pumpkin Spice - Glutarama makes dairy free version

image courtesy of Bailey’s

Just in case you’re interested here’s the original dairy version, which can be bought online at Amazon or while stocks last in ASDA, Sainsbury’s, Tesco, Waitrose and Ocado.

disclaimer: I’ve started using affiliate codes on my website again (needs must). If you click on any of the links in the post and make a purchase my family will benefit from a small % of that purchase at no extra cost to you.