Dairy Free Black Forest Pavlova

This page contain affiliate links. Please refer to my Disclosures Page for more details.

This Dairy Free Black Forest Pavlova began it’s life as a Breton Gateau. Let me rewind and unpick that statement for you!

I made my Gluten Free Breton Gateau with Apricot Filling after years of wanting to make such a bake, but never knowing what to do with the remaining egg whites, I’d put it off. You can see where I’m going with this now can’t you.

I did some research and found a pavlova using 6, that’s SIX egg whites because I needed the egg yolks for the gateau. That’s when I came across Nigella’s Chocolate Pavlova recipe and knew I could adapt it, with a few Rebecca-style tweaks, to be dairy free as well as naturally gluten free.

And so dear reader, my Dairy Free Black Forest Pavlova recipe was born.

How can I make a dairy free pavlova?

To make the pavlova part of this recipe dairy free is simple. It is already dairy free and, as mentioned above, naturally gluten free as it has neither dairy or gluten containing ingredents.

If you’re sitting there thinking that eggs are dairy, go to the back of the class and turn round to face the wall until I say so! While you are there check out this post by Kat from Loopy Whisk Are Eggs Dairy?

The dairy elements of this Black Forest Pavlova are the chocolate cream layer and the final whipped cream layer. These can easily be achieved by using a plant-based cream. I used Heavenly sweetened on this occasion but for more information on what are the best dairy free creams to use check out the next section below.

What are the best vegan creams to use in this recipe?

How do you make a soft Pavlova?

The trick to making a pavlova that’s soft with a marshmallow style centre is to use vinegar. Why does vinegar make a difference? I’m not 100% sure, and much Googling didn’t really answer the question sufficiently, except reinforce the fact that without it you have a firmer meringue. With vinegar you have pillow soft centres. I’ve purposely not said chewy pavlova because you’re not looking to create a chewiness, marshmallow much better describes the perfect results.

You’ll also find many pavlova recipes call for cream of tartar or cornflour (cornstarch) but in the case of this recipe it’s not necessary. The responsibility of the cream of tartar or cornflour is to stabilise the meringue and prevent it seeping. As this pavlova has melted dark chocolate in it the fat helps to bind.

Normally you’d see a white wine vinegar being added to a pavlova but in this case Nigella used balsamic. I think the flavour perfectly matches the deep rich flavour of the chocolate enhancing it further.

Is Balsamic Vinegar Gluten Free?

Balsamic vinegar is naturally gluten free due to the fact it’s made from fermented grapes. It’s essentially a reduction of grape juice into a syrup that’s then fermented and aged not unlike a fine wine.

The topic of vinegars as a whole can be a confusing one and Coeliac UK have changed their take on listing vinegars in their guide that don’t actually test to be gluten free. Barley Malt Vinegar is technically gluten free due to the processes it goes through but CUK have understandably said that the only way to be sure, is for producers to test for ppm (parts per million), and without this seal of approval these vinegars no longer appear in the annual Food & Drink Guide. For more info check out their article here Barley malt vinegar and barley malt extract – suitable for a gluten free diet?

But back to the topic in hand, BALSAMIC VINEGAR is safe for Coeliac diets.

Can I use fresh cherries in this black forest pavlova recipe?

I’ll be honest, I’d not recommend it. Here’s why; to achieve the Black Forest flavours you really need a rich cherry pie filling with lots of delicious sauce. You also need that pow of colour and with fresh cherries, once you’ve stewed them they lose their colour.

Another issue to consider, is that cherries are seasonal and rather expensive whilst a tin or can of cherry pie filling is about £1 and can be found in store all year round.

Of course you could still use a few fresh cherries to decorate, it’s up to you, just remember to de-stone them first or else you’ll be paying people’s dentist bills.

What other flavour fruits can I use on my pavlova?

Moving away from cherries would take away the Black Forest element but there’s nothing to stop you from using other tinned fruits, how about strawberries or rhubarb or even mandarin segments for a chocolate orange flavour sensation.

Please do experiment and have fun swapping out fruits for one another. I’d love to see what you come up with so remember to come back and let me know and tag me in any posts you share on social media.

Can I add alcohol to this Black Forest Dessert?

If you would like to take this Black Forest Pavlova dessert to the next level then you could add some cherry liqueur (liquor) to the chocolate cream layer.

I recommend adding it to that layer because the chocolate cream will take a slug or two of Kirsh or Cherry Brandy and keep its structure, whilst adding it to other elements of the dessert may make them too wet to work with. It also means you get a delicious alcoholic punch to the centre of the dessert which will seep into the soft rich chocolate meringue.

What can I make with leftover egg yolks?

I kind of gave the game away here in the first 20 seconds of reading this recipe post. My Gluten Free Breton Gateau with Apricot Filling is the obvious option given the fact that you have the exact amount of egg yolks required for the recipe. It’s worth pointing out that this recipe is not dairy free, but I do give advice on how to make it dairy free. Obviously it’s gluten free!

Other options would be any of my bread pudding recipes whereby you could add just the yolks to the custard. The pudding will still work, you will just get a richer more golden coloured end bake.

Traditional Gluten Free Bread Pudding

Traditional Gluten Free Bread and Butter Pudding

Easy Gluten Free Chocolate Orange Bread and Butter Pudding

How do I keep this Chocolate Pavlova until ready to serve?

The dessert can be eaten immediately, however, if preparing for an occasion in advance this will keep in the fridge for 1-2 days. The chocolate meringue may bleed a little. This is where the sugars liquify and you end up with a gooey sweet syrup. In the case of this pavlova seepage is minimal and frankly any sweet goo you do get is delicious anyway!

Other Dairy Free Desserts you will want to try

Dairy Free Black Forest Pavlova Recipe

If you make it and like the recipe I would be eternally grateful if you popped back and commented leaving a star rating as this will tell search engines that this recipe is worth checking out and others will get to find it in searches.

I love to see your own photos of my bakes, dinners and treats head to your favourite social media account and don’t forget to tag me in @glutarama

Subscribe to my email list so that you get NEW recipes straight in your mailbox every Friday PLUS a FREEBIE and access to some amazing gluten free DISCOUNTS

*disclaimer: I use affiliate codes on my website, the vast majority are to Amazon. If you click on any of the links or images in the post and make a purchase my family will benefit from a small % of that purchase at no extra cost to you, in fact, for full transparency, in 2020 I made my first £25, and recently in 2022 I reached my next £25 (Amazon don’t transfer the money until you reach £25). As you can see, it won’t make me a millionaire but it will treat me to a few coffees, Lord knows I need the caffeine!